Reputation
9,456
Next privilege 10,000 Rep.
Access moderator tools
Badges
9 38 93
Impact
~767k people reached

Nov
3
comment Where are the dogs in Titanic?
Sorry for the downvote -- just my little opinion -- nothing personal! :)
Nov
3
comment Who kills the priest's dog?
I don't think anyone in the story is pure "good" or "bad." Father James himself resorts to drinking and fighting at one point. And clearly his daughter had complaints about his parenting. I'd say the Father James character faces the same trials faced by the other characters, and all humans: Can he be forgiven? Can he forgive others? And can he let go of the futile desire to control his fate, turning it over to God instead -- even if doing so will be his destruction? (IMHO Father James is a hero because the answer to all three questions is yes.)
Nov
3
comment Where are the dogs in Titanic?
-1: "either they survived or died" does not add any value
Nov
3
comment Where are the dogs in Titanic?
+1 The filmmaker's choice to show the dogs early in the movie will definitely lead some viewers (like OP and me) to wonder what happens to them in the end.
Oct
13
comment Why wasn't Cage strapped in for the final raid?
+1 and accept, thanks very much! Video was bonus. And Cruise character being willing to sacrifice himself makes perfect sense given movie's theme of Cruise character maturing.
Oct
11
comment Why wasn't Cage strapped in for the final raid?
Yes, I understand that. What I don't understand is Cage's plan. Why wasn't he hooked in? Why didn't he tell Rita in advance?
Aug
17
comment Why the title 'Unforgiven' in the movie Unforgiven?
Now that you mention it, just about everyone in the movie is unforgiven for something. This answer deserves a lot more love. :)
Aug
15
comment What happened at the end of A Most Wanted Man?
I love how the question has been viewed over 1000 times and still no likes... something about that fits perfectly with this particular movie.
Aug
11
comment Why did Vincent Vega diss Butch?
+1 I appreciate your follow-up responses (took me awhile to realize you provided them). IMO your thoughts are correct, and I would like to accept your answer... could you edit to add the info in your last comment?
Jul
31
comment A movie about aliens living underground
+1 Good points. Though I've noticed that sometimes the OP's initial recollections aren't 100% accurate.
Jul
31
comment What happened at the end of A Most Wanted Man?
If what you're saying is true, the movie really did not get through to me, because I have no recollection of time being communicated to the viewer via clocks or anything else. And only vague recollection of the 72 hours being mentioned. And no recollection of explanation why Security Agency A would ruin Agency B's mission because something is 10 minutes late. Argh!
Jul
24
comment What's the origin of “Choose life” phrase?
the hairstyles in those Russian stills... priceless!
Jul
10
comment Why did the Great Gasby (2013) movie erase the hints of Nick Carraway's homosexuality?
whoever downvoted - why? (SE protocol is to comment on reason for downvote.)
Jul
10
comment Why did the Great Gasby (2013) movie erase the hints of Nick Carraway's homosexuality?
OK, answer edited to remove question in last paragraph.
Jul
9
comment What did the Meth Head think he was digging for?
This is definitely the right answer. Jesse clearly used the digging ruse to trick Tucker.
Jul
2
comment Was Raoul Silva M's son?
@Napoleon, yes! The final scene with the new M shows that Bond has overcome his personal anger with the previous M and subsequently more fully embraced her overall mission of defending England. It's funny, but at the end of the day, "Skyfall" is all about two middle-aged men processing their mommy issues!
Jul
1
comment Was Raoul Silva M's son?
@Paul, nice catch, thanks -- I just updated. :)
Jul
1
comment Was Raoul Silva M's son?
Good point, thanks -- I edited again. :)
Jun
26
comment The guy who takes over M's position in Skyfall, is he evil or good?
Good point -- I expanded my answer.
Jun
25
comment The guy who takes over M's position in Skyfall, is he evil or good?
This quote from the article agrees with my answer above: "throughout Skyfall, I pegged Fiennes' Mallory as a mole... why else hire such a big name actor to play the part of the government overseer placing hurdles for Dench's M to jump? [But] it became clear when Bond chases Silva into the M/MI-6 hearing and a big shoot out erupts. Mallory didn't miss a shot when assisting Bond and Eve. He was a good guy."