14,414 reputation
439104
bio website
location Chemnitz, Germany
age 27
visits member for 2 years, 4 months
seen 13 mins ago

Got a smoke?


2m
reviewed No Action Needed Who is the serial killer in Memories of Murders?
2m
comment How does Smaug know about the Ring?
How did you get the impression that Smaug knew about the ring and Bilbo having it at all?
3m
reviewed Edit suggested edit on How does Smaug know about the Ring?
3m
revised How does Smaug know about the Ring?
deleted 21 characters in body; edited tags
7m
comment Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
@MeatTrademark And as far as "People even delete the name of the property in the question because it's in the tag." - No, they only delete it from the title, anything else is inappropriate and deserves a change, even if not always someone bothering to edit it may be around. But I guess this comment thread is already a bit long. If you don't have any further questions, feel free to flag those comments for deletion once read.
13m
comment Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
@MeatTrademark Ok, seing that he already wrote a comment under Will's answer, I agree that it was a hit-n-run. But in this case explaining the accept feature (like Will already did himself, though) would have been far more constructive than this comment (it wasn't too evil either, just very unclear and useless, which is why I just flagged it as "obsolete" in contrast to, say, "not-constructive").
29m
comment Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
@MeatTrademark And as to the deleted comment. I, sharing your feelings towards hit-n-run questions, have asked similar things in the past. But there are more polite (and also clearer and more understandable) ways than just writing "Gone . . . . " and also better times to write that, given that you gave him like 3 hours to come back (he isn't even an unregistered user, whatever that means in the end though).
35m
comment Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
@MeatTrademark "I truly don't understand given I've seen the opposite of this so many times." - In this case you probably at least saw an introduction saying something like "I wonder if someone could help me about a movie I been searching for but can't remember" (and if you didn't, well, than nobody bothered to improve the question, I guess). As said, I agree that sentence I added is a bit verbose, but something had to be done about a post that misses any kind of context or actual question.
39m
comment Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
@MeatTrademark I agree that this last sentence I added is a bit useless, but even more than that it makes the post an actual question. You just deleted too much (while I agree the initial question was a bit too verbose). There has to be a question asked in the question body. This is not about undermining your authority as editor, but only about making questions that, well, ask questions. Of course from the fact that it was posted as a question we could always deduce the actual question, but in the same way that we don't rely on the title to provide context, we also don't rely on the tags.
46m
comment When/Why did American television change from primarily episodic to primarily serialized?
This doesn't seem to adress the actual question, though.
48m
revised Why was Harry's condition so different from his father's
deleted 6 characters in body
10h
comment Where do Sam & Dean get money from?
Doesn't sound too likely. Do you have any references or other inormation to support this theory?
10h
revised Where do Sam & Dean get money from?
deleted 7 characters in body
10h
revised Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
added 38 characters in body
12h
reviewed Approve suggested edit on Why does Bernadette work at the Cheesecake Factory?
12h
revised Guy uses bike to recharge, and a guy who remains frozen most of the time
edited tags
15h
comment @Midnight end credits
@MeatTrademark There are indeed many other tags that don't have more than one unanswered question (some to blame on me), but that's just a consequence of the general policy of creating tags for each and every movie/TV-show. Yet this policy is a given nevertheless and not to be suspended for an anticipated lack of interest in the respective movie/TV-show. But that just as a general information. "nor does it have stories or questions to worry about" - Yes it does, you asked one. ;-) "as it's not scripted" - I'm unsure about the ontopicness of those anyway, but the community seemingly isn't
16h
comment how can I follow new episodes coming out?
@downvoter I wonder though who would downvote this, since it seems pretty much what the OP is looking for (given a US-background that is probably suggested by his usage of another .com site and his lack in clarifying another cultural background), no matter if that was off-topic in the first place.
16h
comment Why didn't the bomb detonate earlier?
"If you accept that Omnicorp is deliberately maiming cops to generate fodder for the program." - I didn't consider this in any way, but it might make sense. Would have to watch the movie again, though.
18h
revised What is the Butterfly-Effect in Mr. Nobody?
edited body