meta user
network profile
| bio | website | |
|---|---|---|
| location | ||
| age | ||
| visits | member for | 6 months |
| seen | Jun 9 at 16:53 | |
| stats | profile views | 3 |
|
Jun 5 |
comment |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? @Tom But surely, the majority of movie watchers will never consciously pick up on this happening or ever be aware of it. That doesn't mean that it wasn't an intentional directing decision, however. I believe Bane's voice change is in this same vein of subtext/foreshadowing. Given that -all- of Bane's voice was dubbed in post, and that -all- of his voice would have been thoroughly combed over in the movie with a fine-toothed comb (esp. w/ post-post processing), I wager that Nolan wouldn't let something "slip" so (relatively) drastically as the vocal/pitch change in this scene. Just my opinion. |
|
Jun 5 |
comment |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? @Tom Not necessarily. If it is intentional, I don't believe that it's meant to be an overtly "conscious" addition, but rather, a bit of foreshadowing and/or subtext. Like the scene with Bruce at the charity ball -- Miranda approaches Bruce holding a masquerade mask over her face as she meets him for the first time, before pulling the mask away. No doubt this is an intentional point of subtext and foreshadowing for her character, alluding to the both literal and figurative "mask" that she holds over her character and her ensuing deception toward Bruce. |
|
May 29 |
awarded | Critic |
|
Mar 29 |
revised |
What's on Bane's arms in Dark Knight Rises? added 276 characters in body |
|
Mar 19 |
revised |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? grammatical |
|
Mar 17 |
comment |
What's on Bane's arms in Dark Knight Rises? That makes sense, I suppose. But even still, with the effect being so blatant, and densely concentrated around the shoulders, I can't help but feel that it's more than just a prosthetic goof. Other scenes with Bane's bare arms don't suffer from this. On the other hand, however, I suppose it could be because of the water involved in this scene, and maybe it was too difficult to prevent from happening (and maybe Nolan even thought it added to the grittiness of Bane). |
|
Mar 15 |
comment |
What's on Bane's arms in Dark Knight Rises? Great idea -- done! :) |
|
Mar 15 |
revised |
What's on Bane's arms in Dark Knight Rises? added 151 characters in body |
|
Mar 15 |
revised |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? added 438 characters in body |
|
Mar 15 |
revised |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? added 397 characters in body |
|
Mar 15 |
comment |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? I rephrased the question to avoid the angle of comparing it to a question of whether Bane's voice was post-production'ed or not. I also added some further thoughts and analysis on the matter. |
|
Mar 15 |
revised |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? Formatting |
|
Mar 15 |
revised |
Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? formatting |
|
Mar 13 |
asked | Does Bane's voice change in this scene because of plot? |
|
Mar 13 |
asked | What's on Bane's arms in Dark Knight Rises? |
|
Dec 18 |
awarded | Scholar |
|
Dec 3 |
awarded | Supporter |
|
Dec 2 |
awarded | Student |
|
Dec 2 |
awarded | Editor |
