5,243 reputation
42364
bio website
location Germany
age 27
visits member for 2 years, 7 months
seen 8 hours ago

.NET Software Developer


Jun
5
revised Age issue in How Old Are You
The question asks for a plot-explanation. movie-mistakes should stay reserved for questions about officially acknowledged mistakes, we don't need another plot-inconsistency tag.
Jun
5
reviewed No Action Needed Train scene in the movie “Shame”
Jun
5
reviewed Leave Open Age issue in How Old Are You
Jun
5
reviewed Leave Open Details of projects done by R Diwakar
Jun
5
accepted Why did the Others put Karl in the chair in Room 23?
Jun
4
reviewed No Action Needed Whose picture is it anyway?
Jun
4
reviewed No Action Needed A writer tries to escape from her surreal, post apocalyptic novel
Jun
4
comment Why did Malvo do the things he did to Stavros Milos?
Not sure his motivations have been answered by the show yet, but a good question nontheless.
Jun
4
reviewed Approve suggested edit on Why did the Others put Karl in the chair in Room 23?
Jun
4
comment Whose picture is it anyway?
Not to forget executive producers who make the movie possible from an organisational and financial point of view, editors, cutters, CGI and other post production staff who have a large influence on atmosphere, tone, visual and audio experience. As you said, its a collaborative effect, even if the director usually gets most of the credit in the end.
Jun
4
revised How does an average (non-star) actor's pay work?
production tag, because it's a production question :)
Jun
4
comment Whose picture is it anyway?
Can you give a clearer definition what exactly you want to know? A movie is project created by a multitude of people. How do you define the "ownership" you are talking about?
Jun
4
comment Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
@Paulster2 Interesting theory, you might want to post that as an answer. Carol did not have a phaser at that time. Also I noticed that he was hit directly in the face in that scene, might play into the different effect as well.
Jun
4
comment Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
Fair enough, I have no comment by the producers to back this up, if that's what you are looking for.
Jun
4
comment Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
Yes, the first shot hits him before he is standing completely. It's still not a surprise shot as the one from Scotty on the bridge, where he thought the situation was under control and did not expect anything. If you want to badly label this as a script error, I won't be able to convince you. I still think this is a reasonable in-universe explanation. There certainly was no difference in the phasers, and both times they were set to stun. (They needed him alive on the barge to rescue Kirk.)
Jun
4
revised Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
edited body
Jun
4
comment Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
The only in-universe explanation that makes sense to me is that he has to prepare himself to withstand the phaser shot. If you watch the barge scene, you see that he has a few seconds before Uhura shoots him. As I said above, he simply was not ready when Scotty hit him.
Jun
4
comment Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
I suspect that his powers are great enough that he would have been able to withstand the phasers much easier and take down Uhura if he wasn't already exhausted at this point.
Jun
4
answered Why does Harrison show different reactions to phaser fire?
Jun
4
revised What is the equivalent of 555 for postal addresses?
rephrased the title to a complete sentence