New answers tagged how-i-met-your-mother
I found it! It's the 11th episode from Season 6, The Mermaid Theory.
It is that most likely the producers shot this flash back scene back in season 7 as they had access to Katie Holmes being the slutty pumpkin in the backround during the production of the episode. They probably saved and later edited this clip into season 9 for the flash back footage, this can be confirmed by a few simple observations between the s7 episode ...
Top 50 recent answers are included