Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Was the twist in the 75th Hunger Games predetermined to send the victors back in, or was it changed by President Snow when he needed a way to get rid of Katniss? The Quarter Quells are the only Games that are different. This is convenient since the President needs one.

share|improve this question
    
Related movies.stackexchange.com/questions/18956/… maybe dupe based on answer – cde Feb 11 at 19:30
    
@cde This seems the more general question though and quite different from the specific question what Heavensbee did there. But sure, related it definitely is, even if not a duplicate. – Napoleon Wilson Feb 12 at 13:32
up vote 23 down vote accepted

It is unknown whether Snow changed the plan for the third quarter quell to send Katniss back into the Games but it is likely that he did.

A great number of the games were planned at the outset of the creation of the Hunger Games, including the concept of the Quarter Quell having an extra twist, but there's no information, either in the films or in the books that definitively say whether what occurred in the 75th Hunger Games was the plan or whether Snow changed it.

Every 25 years there is a Quarter Quell edition of the Hunger Games. Quells mark the anniversaries of the districts' defeat by the Capitol, and include special celebrations. The Games involves some sort of twist that makes them even more disastrous or difficult to compete in, or watch. A small box contains small yellow envelopes containing specific themes or twists for each Quarter Quell. These instructions were planned at the founding of the Hunger Games, with plans in place for hundreds of Games. The President at the time selects the appropriate card and reads it on live television to announce the theme of that year's Quell. It is unknown how many Quarter Quells were planned ahead of time, but some suspect that the 75th had been changed so that Katniss Everdeen, the female tribute from District 12 who won the previous year and the district's sole living female Victor, would be forced to go back into the arena once more (this is confirmed in a deleted scene in the film adaption of The Hunger Games: Catching Fire).

One point made in the article argues that it's unlikely that it was planned from the beginning... there was no way the founders could predict that there would be appropriate candidates for the games if this were the case. Until Katniss won the 74th Games with Peeta, there was no living female Victor from District 12, and it's unknown whether there had ever been one at all:

The 75th Hunger Games had past victors from earlier Hunger Games compete for a second time. This action was made to destroy any bonds the districts had with each other and to make them feel weak. It was meant to be a reminder to the citizens of the districts that even the strongest among them cannot overcome the power of the Capitol. It is speculated that this twist was not planned at the founding of the Hunger Games, but was designed specifically to force Katniss back into the arena in the hopes of stopping the rising rebellion. Even if this twist was planned in advance, it wouldn't have been possible if Katniss had not won the previous year's Hunger Games, as there would be no living female victor from District 12. The 75th Hunger Games were the last Games hosted.

share|improve this answer
1  
Is the "living female from 12" really an thing? To me, the issue is more the side-stepping of the rules (2 Victors) and - more importantly - the knowledge that Capitol's rule wasn't absolute (1 victor? Okay, lets eat the berries). The "Twist" (previous victors) was to get the "rebels" (2 victors who flaunted the rules) back into the "ring" and dead "by the rules" - and not as martyrs. – WernerCD Feb 11 at 22:20
1  
@WernerCD all of the districts chose one male and one female Victor. If they generically took two, then there could have been an uneven number of each. In both the film and the books, they make a point of the pageantry that was pointless in drawing Katniss' name, considering she was the only female tribute available from 12... and, until the 74th Games, there was only one living tribute (Haymitch)... so there wouldn't have been two to send at all. – Catija Feb 11 at 22:24
5  
It would be nice if you could include the relevant quotes from the books. Katniss spends a bit of time talking about the cards and how they were stored, highlighting that no one new what they said and that only the president (I think) had any sort of access to them. As such, they might all have been blank, filled out the year they were used. There also might be something about the handwriting used on the cards. – Trisped Feb 12 at 1:33
2  
@Trisped If you feel my answer is lacking, you are more than welcome to add your own answer. – Catija Feb 12 at 3:05
1  
It is unknown (whether), but likely (that), (-whether-) Snow changed the plan for the third quarter quell to send Katniss back into the Games. I'm sorry my inner grammar nazi made me do it. – lorless Feb 12 at 14:57

TLDR:

We don't know conclusively, but it's almost certain that the 75th Games (which were planned) were altered to include former winners so as to kill off Katniss (and subdue the rebellion).

Answer:

I think you've answered your own question.

In Catching Fire, following Katniss and Peeta's victories, frustration among the people is growing. They have seen two people defy the Capitol and Katniss in particular is becoming a symbol of rebellion.

Snow wanted Katniss and Peeta killed at the end of the Hunger Games, for their "stunt" with the berries. But Seneca Crane instead announced them as winners (and paid for it with his life). So now Snow is aware that both Peeta and particularly Katniss are symbols, and a threat. The film echoes the book in this regard, and to quote from the book:

...You have no access to information about the mood in other districts. In several of them, however, people viewed your little trick with the berries as an act of defiance, not an act of love. And if a girl from District Twelve of all places can defy the Capitol and walk away unharmed, what is to stop them from doing the same?” he says. “What is to prevent, say, an uprising?”

...

“Why don't you just kill me now?” I blurt out.
“Publicly?” he asks. “That would only add fuel to the flames.”
“Arrange an accident, then,” I say.
Who would buy it?” he asks. “Not you, if you were watching.

...

“Only you'll have to do even better if the uprisings are to be averted,” he says. “This tour will be your only chance to turn things around.

“I know. I will. I'll convince everyone in the districts that I wasn't defying the Capitol, that I was crazy with love,” I say.

President Snow rises and dabs his puffy lips with a napkin. “Aim higher in case you fall short.”

“What do you mean? How can I aim higher?” I ask.

“Convince me” he says.

So at this Stage, Snow wants Katniss on board. He is hesitant to kill her, as it will stir rebellion - but he can't let her "go free", as she will stir rebellion. So he wants her to behave well and do as he says.

Of course, this fails. She pays tribute to Rue in District 11 and sparks visible dissent. A man in the crowd is shot dead and tension is clearly rising.

At this point, Snow is even more concerned. Something the book mentions, which the movie does not, is the following scene which takes place in the mayor's house (during her tour of the districts):

I'm leaving the room when a beeping noise catches my attention. I turn back to see the screen of the television go black. Then the words “UPDATE ON DISTRICT 8” start flashing. Instinctively I know this is not for my eyes but something intended only for the mayor. I should go. Quickly. Instead I find myself stepping closer to the television.

An announcer I've never seen before appears. It's a woman with graying hair and a hoarse, authoritative voice. She warns that conditions are worsening and a Level 3 alert has been called. Additional forces are being sent into District 8, and all textile production has ceased.

They cut away from the woman to the main square in District 8. I recognize it because I was there only last week. There are still banners with my face waving from the rooftops. Below them, there's a mob scene. The square's packed with screaming people, their faces hidden with rags and homemade masks, throwing bricks. Buildings burn. Peacekeepers shoot into the crowd, killing at random.

I've never seen anything like it, but I can only be witnessing one thing. This is what President Snow calls an uprising.

So there is full rebellions occurring now, across all of the suppressed districts. Snow's plan of keeping Katniss "on-side" has failed. Inadvertently, through her tributes to Rue and simply by her being strife is brewing and more signs of dissent are breaking out.

This is when Snow hatches the master plan to send Katniss back into The Hunger Games.

Katniss realises that she'll likely die from this:

“If you're perfectly honest about it, you think President Snow has probably given them direct orders to make sure we die in the arena anyway,” I say.

“It's crossed my mind,” says Peeta.

It's crossed my mind, too. Repeatedly. But while I know I'll never leave that arena alive, I'm still holding on to the hope that Peeta will. After all, he didn't pull out those berries, I did. No one has ever doubted that Peeta's defiance was motivated by love. So maybe President Snow will prefer keeping him alive, crushed and heartbroken, as a living warning to others.

Now, at the start of the Catching Fire novel, Effey tells Katniss "In your very first year of being a victor, you get to be a mentor in a Quarter Quell!

Our only knowledge of a Quarter Quell comes frmo a recollection Katniss had:

But in school I remember hearing that for the second Quarter Quell, the Capitol demanded that twice the number of tributes be provided for the arena. The teachers didn't go into much more detail, which is surprising, because that was the year District 12's very own Haymitch Abernathy won the crown.

So we know the Quarter Quell is designed to be special. But given Effey's comments, and the knowledge that former winners are supposed to be exempt it seems almost overwhelmingly likely the rules were changed so as to trap Katniss in a situation where she could be killed without sparking further unrest.

Conclusion:

We don't definitively know. There were going to be Hunger Games that year. But it's overwhelmingly likely that the Games were altered to include Katniss.

share|improve this answer

Some good answers before this one but all of them sidelined one crucial detail or rather person: Plutarch Heavensbee (RIP Mr Hoffman)

After Crane was killed due to the debacle of 74th Hunger Games, we see Plutarch being appointed as head Gamekeeper and a very close associate of President Snow. Plutarch was giving an angry and anxious Snow valuable feedback and advice on how to tackle Katnis and defuse the uprising.

It is only later we find out that Plutarch has ulterior motives in being so close to Snow and the Games itself.

Plutarch has an elaborate plan to take Katnis away from Capitol's clutches.

We also find out that most of the tributes of 75th Hunger Games, all of them being previous Victors, are in on his elaborate plan. It is highly likely that the plan was brewing much before Katnis came on the scene, much before 74th Hunger Games. Because forming an alliance will take much time and effort and trust. They all were waiting for a right time and a right person to galvanize their fight against the Capitol. And since Katnis served that purpose perfectly, Plutarch must have decided its time to implement his plan.

Plutarch knew Katnis enough to know that she was impulsive and brave even under mortal fear. He knew the Victory tour would not go according to Snow's plans, which were suggested to Snow by Plutarch himself. To paraphrase "Distract people with the wedding. Show her as one of us now. They will hate her so much, they might just kill her for you"

So, it is more likely that after Snow's plan, mentioned above, failed. Plutarch convinced Snow that the right way to kill Katnis would be under the guise of another Hunger Games rather than shooting her on point-blank. And since 75th Hunger Games were Quarter Quill, they had a disguise for their plan.

So, it is most likely Plutarch's idea to have Victors as tributes to the 75th Hunger Games and since most are in on his plan, and were ready to sacrifice their life for Katnis's safety, he knew that his plan would work. So he manipulated Snow's decision

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.