Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Now before I say this I understand that The Dark Knight Rises was set in the real world and not in comics but the Bane in comics was hilarious. Are there any comments from Christopher Nolan or Tom Hardy about the reason they went in this direction

Why did Bane turn from this.................................................................Into this? enter image description here

share|improve this question
3  
"I understand that..." - Not sufficiently enough, it seems. ;-) –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 15 at 13:54
    
Related: movies.stackexchange.com/q/3814/49. –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 15 at 13:55
1  
While I have absolutely no practical comic background information, I thought that he wasn't unintelligent there either. But nevermind, I think they've made such extensive changes to so many characters that this seems quite natural. However, this is not to say that your question isn't a valid or interesting one, even if a likely answer might just be "to bring him more in line with the rest of the movies' tone and story". –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 15 at 13:59
2  
Well, by using MS Paint, haha. ;-) –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 15 at 14:19
3  
Bane is a mastermind in the comics. He is very intelligent, deduced Batman's secret identity through observation, and set off the events in the Knightfall. Yes he is capable of brute force, but is also a strategist and tactician. That is how he wore Batman down enough that he could beat him in single combat. –  Leatherwing Aug 15 at 16:18

2 Answers 2

up vote 5 down vote accepted

The movie is based largely on the Knightfall series of comics where Bane is highly intelligent. On his wiki one of his abilities is "Genius Level Intellect".

As to his meticulous controlling personality, the early versions of Bane were just this.

Bane creator Chuck Dixon's early tales portray Bane as a very calm, centered warrior akin to Bruce Lee in as much that he draws strength through calm meditation, and the spiritual energy of the "very rock of Peña Dura" - Wikipedia

share|improve this answer
1  
I know he is super intelligent what i don't understand is why they made him so controlled and also took away the Venom aspect. by the end of the movie he seems more like a sad puppy than a super strong excaped con –  Flaunting Aug 15 at 14:21
1  
Then I'd adjust your question and title to reflect what you're actually looking for. The movie follows the Knightfall series where Bane is quite controlled, cunning and intelligent. –  Chad Kapatch Aug 15 at 14:23

For the same reason that Ra's Al Ghul's regeneration and resurrection abilities have been reduced to trickery, allusions and a mere philosophical immortality of his presence and why various plot elements or characters were changed from the comic source material. To bring him more in line with the movie's style, atmosphere and setting. Nolan's take on Batman is centered around a very realistic and serious imagining of the whole Batman universe, like all this could actually exist easily in our own reality.

And you certainly hit it on the head when you say "the Bane in comics was hilarious". Especially the whole Venom aspect is way too over-the-top for this. While the movies might really scratch the edge of technological plausibility at times (stupid cell-phone radars anyone?) they are far from the domain of Science Fiction or Fantasy, not only regarding the tech, but the whole style and presentation as very serious crime thriller dramas. Sure, the Venom aspect is not too fictitious, but the whole depiction of a half-naked muscle machine driven by huge tubes pumping his body full with some magical super-soldier serum is just a bit too over-the-top to fit into the serious and realistic universe we've been presented so far.

He also doesn't seem to see much reason in putting on some strange Mexican wrestler mask for disguise or threatening. Add to this also the not to underestimate fact that in a movie seeing the actor's eyes gives him much more ways for expression and can add way more to his presence than a weird mask. He also seems to prefer more useful and protective clothing.

But still Bane wasn't changed completely:

  • In his answer Chad already alludes to the fact that even the comic Bane was quite intelligent.
  • His background as a man grown-up in prison is still there (even if his geographic origin was altered).
  • The Venom aspect also was not entirely dropped but just heavily toned down into a mere face-mask supplying him with anaesthetics or painkillers. And you could actually argue that those painkillers/anaesthetics are indeed giving him unnormal strength and endurance in the way that increased tolerance to pain enables you to go far beyond your normal capabilities. So it is pretty much a realistic interpretation of Venom. The mask even slightly resembles the original a bit.
  • And also the movie-Bane is still quite a heavy chunk of a man who easily trumps Batman in a physical fight and who doesn't hesitate to show us his muscles.

He was simply adapted for the movie's setting. And we wouldn't want to see this in a Nolan-movie ;-):

enter image description here

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.