Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Dark Knight Rises there is a scene where batman and Catwoman are on the roof, Catwoman disappears and leaves Batman on his own he then says,

So that's what that feels like

My question is knowing he is alone (which he does) why doesn't Bruce just speak normally instead of using the gruffled bat/Scooby-Doo voice.

share|improve this question
6  
+1 for "scooby doo voice". :) –  mskfisher Aug 13 at 12:29

3 Answers 3

up vote 44 down vote accepted

Despite frequently being ridiculed, according to the (now made unavailable) production notes for Batman Begins; Wayne is incapable of speaking without the Bat-voice when he is wearing his Cowl.

According to original drafts for the film:

"High-gain stereo microphones are concealed in the ears, allowing Batman to eavesdrop on distant conversations," the notes describe. The mikes can also amplify Batman's voice and broadcast it through a discreet speaker in the suit, giving his voice that distinctively gruff, disembodied sound.

While the original script included a scene that went over these Bat-details, mentions of Batman's embedded vocal distorter wound up being cut from the final film. (Still, the Batsuit's tiny speakers remained visible upon close inspection.)

enter image description here

In discussing how he realized the mindset of Batman, Bale notes that his Batvoice contributed to him winning the role:

"I got there. They put me in Val Kilmer's suit. It didn't even fit properly, and I stood in it and I went 'I feel like an idiot.' What kind of guy walks around, dressed like a bat? And is then going to go 'Hello, how are you? Just ignore that I'm dressed as a bat.' Of course, he's meant to be doing this. If you look at the history of the guy and the pain that he went through. I went 'I can't do this in a normal voice. I have to become a beast in order to sell this to myself.'"

Whilst he isn't exactly 'going method' for the role of Batman, Bale indicates that for the character of Wayne, putting on the Batsuit is assuming a certain persona, as opposed to merely wearing a disguise.

In order to sustain the mindset of 'the beast', its plausible that when he dons the suit he becomes Batman, and this is a psychological state of which he is unwilling or unable to simply 'switch off', voice included.

share|improve this answer
2  
I'd add to the excellent reasonig at the end, that he didn't just stay in character for himself, but also for us the audience, since he was not alone when seeing it as what it is, a movie and, given that it's such a small comedic throwaway line, he didn't say this so much to himself but more to us. –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 13 at 9:44
16  
Further, as per the standard character of Batman in the comics and even some TV shows, Batman no longer considers himself to be Bruce Wayne. When asked about it by people that know he's Batman, he tells them, "Bruce Wayne died in an alley with his parents." Batman is all he is now. In an episode of Batman Beyond, Terry asks Bruce how he knew the voices he was hearing weren't actually in his head. His response: "...the voice kept calling me "Bruce." In my mind, that's not what I call myself." Bruce Wayne is merely a persona Batman uses, but it's not who he is anymore. –  MattD Aug 13 at 12:55
    
i.e. "I am Iron Man." –  Lightness Races in Orbit Aug 13 at 15:04
    
+1 for "psychological state". Bravo @ MattD !! Bruce Wayne is not a normal person. Batman no longer considers himself to be Bruce Wayne. He is a schizophrenic who decides to fight crime. Many people who lost parents lost mind too. Some start commits crimes, some few fight against. –  Magno C Aug 15 at 11:43
    
@LightnessRacesinOrbit exactly what are you trying to say here??? –  Cool_Coder Aug 19 at 14:13

Most superheroes are, psychologically speaking, more-or-less regular people who adopt a superhero guise to fight crime. Hal Jordan turns into Green Lantern, Peter Parker becomes Spider-Man, and so on. In his modern incarnations, even Clark Kent (who is not precisely "normal", but is as close as he could get under the circumstances) becomes Superman.

Batman is different. The vigilante known as Batman is that person's "default" psyche. He adopts the Bruce Wayne guise in order to function in society in any context other than crimefighting. Even his own comrades don't work this way: Dick Grayson became Robin during his tenure, Barbara Gordon became Batgirl (and then Oracle, and then Batgirl again), and so forth. But Batman turns into Bruce Wayne.

This is a concept that has been explored in a number of Batman-related media. The most stark example may be in an episode of Batman Beyond, where a villain is projecting voices into his head. He realizes that this is a trick when the voices start to speak of him as Bruce, because, as he puts it, "that's not what I call myself in my head." Another example comes from The Sandman, which shows us the dreams of various superheroes. Most of them show up in their civilian guises in their dreams, but Batman does not.

Given all of this, it makes sense that he would talk to himself in the Batvoice: that's his normal head-voice. His "normal" voice is actually the fake one.

share|improve this answer
1  
Is this Sandman or The Sandman? I don't remember this appearing in either, to be honest: which issue did this occur? –  John Smith Optional Aug 13 at 16:03
2  
@JohnSmithOptional Did you intentionally get the links backwards or was it just amusing coincidence? –  Joe Aug 14 at 2:32
    
Whoops! Still... I 'm waiting on an answer on this, from anyone. I'm very well versed with The Sandman (that had better be the right link), and whilst Batman appeared briefly I don't ever remember this being referred to? –  John Smith Optional Aug 14 at 12:56
    
re Sandman comic: Possibly referring to this panel. Superman appears in the Dreaming as Clart Kent during "The Wake", but Batman is in costume. –  Blazemonger Aug 14 at 20:24
    
But now that the comic has exposed that Batman doesn't call himself "Bruce" in his head, the villains can read the comic and next time they'll get it right! –  Almo Aug 16 at 17:53

I disagree with Sonny's response to John Smith Optional's answer completely. As JSO said, once he's in the suit he is 100% committed to being "the beast". He can't afford to come out of character until he's safely at home. You have to realize, Batman isn't your typical superhero. He has no special powers. He's just using technology to his advantage. His weapons are hit gadgets and his mind, and his mind has to stay on-task 100% of the time that he's in the batsuit.

share|improve this answer
2  
If you're responding to a comment, you should comment in the same thread. –  GalacticCowboy Aug 13 at 13:10
2  
I think it stands as it's own answer, which is why I made it one. –  Johnny Bones Aug 13 at 13:16
    
I wasn't arguing with John's answer, though. The last parts of it are exactly spot on. I was simply adding a little more pragmatic and out-of-universe aspect to that. I can't see his answer or yours contradicting this. @GalacticCowboy But I agree with JohnnyBones that this answer here might be able to stand on its own, given that it adds some addional aspects. –  Napoleon Wilson Aug 13 at 13:16

protected by iandotkelly Aug 14 at 19:42

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality answers, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site.

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.