Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I just watched Minority Report again and I always wonder about one part of the story.

When Det. Anderton is about to get his eyes transplanted illegaly, the eye surgeon tells him, that he got imprisoned by Anderton in the past, which ended his normal life and made him an illegal eye surgeon in a shabby apartment after a not very nice time in prison.

I wonder though why he then helped Anderton, considering that he already got paid (I think) and Anderton was already about to anesthesize. He could just have left him blind or do whatever to him. But he doesn't do anything bad to him (well, he left the rotten food right next to the good food in the fridge, but I'm not sure if this was intentional besides not being that evil a trick).

He tells Anderton something about learning new things in prison and finding himself, but this sounded a bit sarcastic and I don't really believe he was actually happy to have been imprisoned.

So my question is:

  • Was this just a plot device which wasn't thought out that well (raise the tension by implying the eye surgeon is evil, which he then isn't)?
  • Was the eye surgeon really happy to have been imprisoned?
  • Has he just got over it and forgiven Anderton and now only does his job?
  • Or was there indeed something I may have overseen in the story?
share|improve this question
I am curious to see whether anyone can shed some light on this scene. Personally I hated this part of the movie, the characters seem out of place, the surgeons cold so extremely portrayed, the rotten food so obvious. – iandotkelly May 6 '12 at 3:51
I agree, this bit always seems badly thought through to me as well. Don't forget the doctor also gives him the muscle relaxant device for free - he goes out of his way to help him! – Mark Jul 16 '12 at 11:35
What bugs me about this scene is how the doctor tells Anderton that if he doesn't wait twelve hours or however long it was before removing his bandages, he'd be blind. But then Anderton takes the bandage off one of his eyes way too early when the spider things come. So that should mean that Anderton is blind in one eye now, right? Which ties into the blind drug dealer guy from the beginning's line about the one eyed man being king or something like that. Except Anderton isn't blind in one eye. At least, he doesn't seem to be blind in one eye. So why did the doctor tell him he would be if h – user4543 Apr 7 '13 at 20:26
up vote 18 down vote accepted

Great sample of the dialog by the way, between Anderton and Dr. Solomon Eddie at IMDB.

While the doctor was describing his experience in prison, his um difficulties in the shower, notice something? Something not in his words, but in his tone. He's dispassionate. He's not angry. I think he actually was reformed. Now he just wants to make a living. He talks as if he's going to mete revenge on Anderton. But never does. He's actually thanking him for turning his life around. I mean, a plastic surgeon who sets his patients on fire for entertainment -- look how far he's come. And he knows it. (This is a better question than I first thought.)

There was also the creepy assistant. Doctor talked at one point as if his assistant saved Anderton, because she had a kind of crush on him. But I don't think that's the real reason the doctor helps Anderton. He's way cynical, to be sure, but he's resigned to a boring life of relatively unremarkable crime. And he's okay with that. So maybe he kinda owes Anderton in the end.

@Shane F. makes an excellent point: the doctor's back-story is a plot device meant to call his trustworthiness [and motives] into question, thereby boosting the suspense about whether he will help or hurt Anderton.

Notice how often this movie tricks you with the good-guy / bad-guy dichotomy. Witwer (Colin Farrell) seems bad but turns out good. Von Sidow seems good but turns out bad. Other characters are more nuanced than pure good or pure evil. This doctor character was just one more bad guy that wasn't all bad.

share|improve this answer
+1 I agree that the doctor truly did see the light in jail. I would just add that, yes, the doctor's back-story is also a plot device meant to call his trustworthiness into question, thereby boosting the suspense about whether he will help or hurt Anderton. – Shiz Z. Dec 18 '13 at 1:15

He did it because

  1. He was hired through "a mutual friend," who must have been the eyeless wiff dealer, and so was partially bound by this relationship.
  2. He was a businesses man, and probably knew that you don't screw over your clients.
  3. He actually cared about doing a good job, you can see it in his demeanor and actions (but doing a good job on eyes, does not mean not messing with him with the sandwich and milk).
  4. He still was mad about being jailed, but kind of knew it was his own fault, and probably knew that if it hadn't been John that put him away, it would have been someone else.
  5. Yes, plot device, and a vehicle for 2 cool characters and a cool scene.
share|improve this answer

The reason because the surgeon helps Anderton is that prison confinement showed to him a unknown side of his personality: he got bisexual tendency. This the line:

Dr. Solomon: "For true enlightenment there is nothing like... well, let's just say taking a shower while this large fellow with an attitude you couldn't knock down with a hammer, that keeps whispering in your ear: Oh nancy, Oh nancy. Now that was a lot of fun, thank you so very much John for putting me in there, thank you so very much for giving me an opportunity to get to know myself much better."

he said "Now that (the event in which the man whisper him during shower was probably a raping, also defined "true enlightenment" about his sexual taste) was a lot of me an opportunity to get to know myself much better" could be read in ironic way but in this case you have to intend in strictly literal way! So dr. Salomon is grateful to Anderton for this wondeful discovery and now he want heartly gives something in return.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.