Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There is a scene in A Clockwork Orange I'm curious about how they done it. Alex is saved by two policemen who turn out to be Dim and Georgie (his old droogs). They drag Alex to the countryside, where they beat and nearly drown him.

It looks like Alex is holding his breath the whole scene. Is this right? Also there is a cut after ~10 seconds. Maybe they give Alex the chance to take a breath with this cut.

The scene is about 60 seconds. I think a average person can hold his breath about this time. But they shouldn't have to do it so.

The scene I'm talking about:

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

up vote 6 down vote accepted

According to IMDb, he did not have to hold his breath. They used an oxygen tank:

In the Warner Brothers DVD, McDowell does a commentary track and talks about how he used an oxygen tank while he was under the water. He never mentions that it failed or that he almost drowned. Also on one of the documentaries on the DVD, the commentator mentions that McDowell did 28 takes of that scene, so the tank must have been working.

And a relevant bit from an online 2002 interview with McDowell:

Q: How long were [you] down in the drowning scene?

MM: Was it that long? Well, it's a trick.

Q: Did you have air?

MM: Of course I did! Are you kidding? It was freezing water. You put your head down in freezing water you can only stay down for three seconds. That was it. England in the winter time - they couldn't even heat the trough. They put some dye in it, barberil - three or four bottles of this, and beef extract. They put [an] oxygen tank in there with a mouth piece. It was like bobbing for apples. Once I had it we were in good shape.

So the rumor going around that McDowell nearly died during that scene seems bogus. However, McDowell implies that he did initially have some problems with the apparatus in this interview:

So Stanley actually put an oxygen tank in the thing with a (tube), but I don't know how many takes before I was able to grab hold of it and then breathe.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.