Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In The Godfather, Part II there's some conflict between Michael and Tom:

TOM: That plane goes to Miami.

MICHAEL: That's where I want it met.

TOM: Mike that's impossible -- they'll turn him over to the Internal Revenue, customs, and half the FBI.

MICHAEL: It's not impossible. Nothing's impossible.

TOM: I'd be like trying to kill the president -- there's no way we can get to him.

MICHAEL: TOM, you know you surprise me -- if anything in this life is certain -- if history has taught us anything -- it's that you can kill anybody. ROCCO?

ROCCO: Difficult -- not impossible.

TOM: Why did you ask me if something was wrong when I came in?

MICHAEL: I thought you were goin' to tell me that -- you were going to move your family to Vegas -- and that you'd been offered the vice-presidency of the house and hotels there I thought you were goin' to tell me that.

TOM: I turned them down -- do I have to tell you about ever offer I turn down?

MICHAEL: let's do business.

TOM: Alright -- just consider this Mike -- that's all just consider it. Now ROTH and the Rosato's are on the run -- are they worth it? And are they strong -- is it worth it -- I mean you've won -- do you have to wipe everyone out?

MICHAEL: I don't fell I have to wipe everyone out -- just my enemies -- that's all. You gonna come along with me in these things I have to do -- or what. Because if not you can take your wife, your family, and your mistress -- and move 'em all to Las Vegas.

TOM: Why do you hurt me MICHAEL -- I've always been loyal to you -- I mean what is this.

MICHAEL: So -- you're staying?

TOM: Yes, I'm staying. Now what is it that you want me to do?

What is going on in this scene? Why is Michael suspecting Tom? Why is Tom getting job offers? What is the source of this strain in their relationship? Why does their relationship always seem a little strained?

share|improve this question
    
What mob lawyer wouldn't get job offers? They're famous, in the papers all the time. You think Bruce Cutler didn't get job offers right up until he started his private practice? Tom was the same. He even had to explain he had one, and only one, client when the movie producer wanted him. –  wbogacz Feb 20 at 14:43

4 Answers 4

Tom, being adopted and of Irish descent, was never allowed to be a "made" member. Very similar to Henry Hill in Goodfella's. This always made Tom feel distant from Michael and Sonny. He knew he could never be a true, full member of the family.

As Napoleon pointed out, by this time Michael was becomming paranoid of everyone. Tom was more interested in keeping peace, and to some degree he twisted some facts to get Michael to back down on his personal vengeance spree. That whole thing about leaving Roth alone was more about keeping the family out of a war than anything else. Tom was more practical that way.

share|improve this answer

Ok, I'll give it a first try, but this may not be too complete (and I haven't seen it for quite some time).

In fact Tom's role in the family has always been a bit difficult. While he is to some degree a member of the family (and not just the "family", but the real Corleone family core) and has always been a valuable member, he on the other hand has never been a complete member and thus there was always a bit of a border (be it only a small one), which didn't allow him to take any more responsibilities in the business than those of the Consigliere (which is still an important role, of course). And I think especially between Michael and Tom there has been a little bit of a distance, at least a larger one than between Tom and any of the other brothers, even if Michael probably valued and respected Tom very high, of course. This is adressed in some dialogue in the movie (or maybe the first part?), I think, when Tom says to Michael that he has always felt a bit of a distance from him.

Another aspect is that this dialogue ocurs very late in the movie, I think, and Michael was becoming increasingly paranoid and defensive (which is also evident from this dialogue itself, when he wants to go after Roth for any price), and probably felt abandoned or betrayed by many important people in his life, be it Fredo or Kay. He maybe also remembered the dialogue earlier in the story when Tom asked if he could take a higher position in the business, but was denied (if I remember correctly). So I think he was suspecting Tom to forsake him, too and to cut the connections to the family and the business in order to strive for higher personal success. But in fact Tom has always been one of the most loyal members of the family (maybe even motivated by the fact that he never felt 100% accepted, especially by Michael) and is thus hurt when Michael forgets this.

share|improve this answer

No No No you have it all wrong. The simple answer here is that Michael pushed Tom to the rear because he was plotting his revenge and the wrap on Tom was, although he was a trusted member of the family, he just wasn't a strong "War Time" Consigliere. This thought was first brought up when Sonny wanted to go to the mat after Vito was shot and Tom wanted to make deals calling the whole mess "business". Knowing how Sonny felt about Tom, remember while Tom wanted to make the deal it was Michael who came up with the plan to kill Virgil Sollozzo. Michael was sure not to make the same mistake that Sonny did. Once Michael took over he used his father as his first "Consigliere" saying that there would be no better adviser than his own Dad. That decision prove valuable as it was Vito that sniffed out the entire plot against Michael even telling him that the person who comes to him with the deal is the snitch. Michael had plans on wiping his enemies out and didn't want Tom talking peace around him, which he tried to do right before Michael tells him he can take his entire family and go to Vegas. The question of staying was offered in Italian, which was serious business. To agree to stay is to agree that this was going down Michael's way and there would be no talk of peace. He does use Tom to deliver the message or rather choice of death to Pentangeli (aka Frankie Five Fingers). The next to last scene flashback shows that it wasn't the first time Michael put Tom in his place.

share|improve this answer

*I think Michael wanted Tom gone and got him all the jobs he had turned down plus he (Michael) knew he could manipulate Tom by telling he was respected and a" real brother" as he did the night at the assassination attempt.

Tom wanted to belong and would do anything for it including being loyal and telling Frankie Five Angels to open up his veins and kill himself for going against the family.

Or Tom could take his wife, his kids and his mistress and move to Vegas!

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.