I am trying to find movie that I watched when I was younger. The parts that really stick out in my mind are a sack filled with body parts hanging above a fire and I think somebody using a toad or something to poison an arrow. I think it was made in the late 90's to early 00's. Also, I think it was set in the Civil War era. Any help?
I believe the film you're describing is THE MISSING. It's a 2003 film with Tommy Lee Jones in the Civil War / Wild West era setting and a character gets put in a leather skin sack and roasted over a fire.