Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Breaking Bad Walter wanted Jesse to believe that Gus was behind the poisoning of Brock. Then why would he use Lily Of The Valey, at the risk of it being traced back to him? Won't using Ricin ensure that Jesse believes Gus did it?

share|improve this question
    
But I saw no berries on Walters plant... –  Michelle Jun 2 at 1:45
    
plant is shown after everything has happened, not before. Plus how can we say that Walt used his own plant ? –  Ankit Aug 1 at 10:11

7 Answers 7

In my opinion Walter White is not truly evil. He just want to earn money for his family. His aim is not to kill Brock but to use Jesse's emotion towards Brock in his favor. Ricin is riskier than Lily of the valley. So he used Lily of the valley and removed the Ricin just to put suspicion on Gus.

Note- I haven't completed season 5 yet, so don't know if it is addressed later.

share|improve this answer
2  
Agreed. To give the appearance of being poisoned for a short while as part of his plan to turn Jesse against Gus without really doing any long-term damage. –  EvilDr Nov 19 '13 at 14:11

When Walter White was contemplating how he was going to topple drug kingpin Gustavo Fring, he noticed the potted lilies in his backyard. ("End Times")

Brock Cantillo was poisoned by Walt in an unknown way with the Lily of the Valley berry. The doctors initially thought he was poisoned by ricin as Jesse Pinkman had suggested but later discovered the true toxin. The doctors and Jesse believed that Brock came across the flower growing naturally and ate some poisonous berries. ("Face Off")

After returning home from successfully killing Gus and getting Jesse back on his side, Walt disposed of the Lily plant from his backyard. ("Live Free or Die")

According to the doctors taking care of Brock, Lily of the Valley is not as poisonous as ricin, and they came to the conclusion that Brock might of thought of them as fruits (as they claimed that it would be easy for kids to mistake the venomous plant as consumable), and slipped one in his mouth, causing him to poison himself.

Now the episode makes you believe that Walter White poisoned him, without actual evidence, because he had the plant in his backyard, and disposed of it after killing Gus. Source: http://breakingbad.wikia.com/wiki/Lily_of_the_Valley

So Walter might of wanted to temporarily have Jesse's attention by making him believe Gus poisoned Brock, thus sort of brain-washing Pinkman to get him onboard to kill Gus, without causing real harm to the child.

share|improve this answer

Ricin was always Walt's go-to poison. This is becuase it's not at all common and very hard to detect.

As knowlegable as Gus was, it's very unlikely that he'd know about a poison such as ricin.Gus is a business man nad owner of a chicken franchise, not an expert in chemistry.

If it was actually found to be ricin in brock's system, Jesse would have immediatley blamed Walt despite it coming from his own pack of cigarettes. By using Lily of the Valley (stated in the show as a commonly found poison) it's much easier to believe that Gus could be aware of it.

share|improve this answer

Ricin would have definitely killed Broch and this was not what Walt wanted. So he used a milder stuff just to get the kid ill and then plant suspicion in Jessie's mind. It was not necessary to use Ricin or anything else in particular. I remember the conversation between Jessie and Walt, where Walt says that "think Jessie ! Who do we know, who is known to use children for his own benefit" Walt's whole purpose was to relate Broch's condition to the killing of Tomas, Andrea's 11 year old brother who was killed by Gus's men. This was highly effective in making Jessie believe that Gus was involved.

share|improve this answer

Walter used Lily of the Valley instead of ricin because it has similar attributes to ricin without actually BEING ricin. If it was actually ricin in Brock's system chances are Jesse would have been taken by the FBI.

Also Lily of the Valley has less of a chance of killing the kid so Walt could get Jesse on his side and against Gus without killing the kid (possibly. There's always a chance it could have killed the kid as well. I guess Walt took the gamble deciding that Brock's life wasn't as important as his family's)

share|improve this answer
    
This doesn't seem to add anything to what has been said before in the other answers. I suggest checking out the Tour to get a better idea of how to ask and answer questions. We're not a typical discussion forum. Don't be discouraged, we were all new here at some point. We want people to stick around, so don't take that as an insult, please. Plus, reading the tour will get you a badge. –  Meat Trademark Aug 1 at 10:08

Walter has used Ricin before so if he uses it again then Jesse blames Walt without thinking this far, so he used one he didn't use before and that is commonly available.

share|improve this answer
    
This doesn't seem to add anything to what has been said before in the other answers. I suggest checking out the Tour to get a better idea of how to ask and answer questions. We're not a typical discussion forum. Don't be discouraged, we were all new here at some point. –  Meat Trademark Aug 1 at 10:03
    
Please stick around, we want more minds to ask and answer questions. Read that Tour, get that badge, and settle in. It's a good site and you're welcome here. –  Meat Trademark Aug 1 at 10:14

It would have been a lot easier to get Brock to ingest the pleasant looking berries as apposed to somehow getting the ricin into his food. This coupled with the fact that the Ricin would take a little time to kick in and therefore may not have had the desired affects in time to spur Jesse into his reactions means that this was the better option for Walt in this case.

share|improve this answer

protected by iandotkelly Aug 1 at 12:05

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality answers, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site.

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.