Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

This an old movie, a comedy. It's about a wealthy playboy who's interested in a nice girl. Also, a broke man wants to marry a wealthy but nasty woman. They all meet at a party. The nasty lady says she'll marry the broke man if he'll live with her in her country house as a "trial marriage." Both couples go to the house )I think it's in Scotland). The servants are all shocked at the immorality and quit. The people have no idea how to cook or clean or take care of themselves. There is a big storm, and they run out of food. One of the men accidentally winds up in a woman's bedroom, and there's a big misunderstanding and fight. The playboy sets off in a boat in the storm to get food, or to just leave or something. The broke man and the nice girl hit it off, and get engaged when they realize they're both nice people who can actually do some work and solve problems. The playboy is stuck marrying the nasty lady.

share|improve this question

On Approval (1944) - Movie Poster

On Approval (1944)

Based on a 1926 play by Frederick Lonsdale, this was English actor Clive Brook’s only directorial effort. Sure the release date's off by a decade, but I'm fairly certain this is the film you saw.

The main story follows two impoverished gentlemen, George, the 10th Duke of Bristol and his friend Richard Halton, and their efforts to marry into money, namely wealthy, 41-year-old widow Maria Wislack and her much younger American friend, Helen Hale.

On Approval (1944) - Pic 01 - reduced On Approval (1944) - Pic 04 - reduced

After a party at George's town house, Maria suggests to Richard, that she should take him away for a month ''on approval'' to her Scottish island home. They will spend the days together and each night Richard will row across the lake to the mainland inn. If the two are compatible, they will marry.

The following section covers another plot point you mentioned:

George and Helen decide to join the group, but on reaching Scotland they find the local hotel fully booked; then, since all must live at Maria's home, the prudish servants quit.

On Approval (1944) - Pic 02 - reduced On Approval (1944) - Pic 03 - reduced

How the rest of the movie plays out:

As the days pass, each sees the other for what he or she really is: Helen tells George to marry Maria, who is as selfish as he; Richard discovers he cannot stand Maria. Richard and Helen decide to leave the island together secretly when Helen finds herself attracted to him. After a nightmare-riddden night, Helen and Richard return to the island to confront George and Maria; the sound of the wedding march drowns out the arguing of the four, and in response to a question form the narrator, Helen admits that she has married Richard.

Watch a short clip; the full movie has also been uploaded online.

~ Synopsis edited from DVDtalk, allmovie and Fifty Classic British Films, 1932-1982: A Pictorial Record.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.