Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Throughout the movie, we see a man who has been talking to James Cole with a mysterious voice; Cole asked him about his identity, but he denied to express it. Once Cole doubted a beggar in 1996 to be the owner of that voice, but later Railley understood that he was not that "person". So who was he? And why was he calling Cole "Bob" all the time?

share|improve this question

This character is referred to as Louie/Rasping Voice on IMDb, and feelings are mixed on the interpretation of the character.

In the feedback section of the movie's IMDb page, there is a lot of discussion over the idea that Louie is a fellow time 'volunteer', who has extracted his own teeth to avoid being tracked.

However, other sites, including this one, suggest that Cole might have been hallucinating the entire time and that he has made up the Louie character and the rasping voice in his head.

The reason he was called 'Bob' could be because this is a form of greeting (although the correct pronunciation would be along the lines of "hey, Bub") - however, Cole is called Bob in the future segments, which leads me to believe that he was being mistaken for a different volunteer.

Here is a sample of dialogue that coroborates the fellow traveler theory:

Louie: Where'd they send you?

James Cole: 1990.

Louie: '90! How was it? Good drugs? Lots of pussy? Hey, Bob, you do the job? You find out the big info? Army of the 12 Monkeys?

James Cole: I was supposed to be 1996.

Louie: Science ain't an exact science with these clowns but, they're getting better. You're lucky you didn't end up in ancient Egypt!

share|improve this answer
Really an iteresting part of this weird story. In fact the beggar's theory about emitters in the teeth sounds just like one of those common conspiracy theories such failed existences usually come up with in the movies, so it could just have been an ordinary bum. Yet they really couldn't localize him once he removied his teeth. Quite ambiguous. – Napoleon Wilson Jul 15 '13 at 6:40
One step further. When Jose meets him in the airport to give him the gun, he confirms that removing the teeth disabled their ability to track him. "Hey, why'd you pull out the tooth man? That was nuts." and "You're a hero man. They gave you a pardon. What do you do, you come back and f-ck with your teeth." Cole asks how they found him, and Jose says it was the phone call. – Bon Gart Jul 15 '13 at 18:31

TL/DR: The raspy voice Cole hears without seeing its speaker is an audio hallucination akin to a voice heard by a schizophrenia sufferer. Louie, the toothless time traveler, is a real person -- and after meeting Louie, Cole -- in a state of extreme mental fatigue -- retroactively associates the raspy voice with Louie.

FULL ANSWER: The raspy voice Cole hears without seeing its speaker is an audio hallucination akin to the voices heard by schizophrenia sufferers, who have described the voices as "spoken by an external, commanding authority" (quote from New York Times article about schizophrenia). Note below that in all three scenes with the raspy voice, the voice seems exactly like an external, commanding authority:

  1. first audio hallucination: when Cole has returned to 2025 after his first time mission

    • "How was it? Good drugs? Lotsa pussy?"
    • "Did you find out the big info? Army of the Twelve Monkeys? Where the virus was prior to mutation?"
  2. second audio hallucination: when Cole has returned to 2025 after his second time mission

    • "You sure fucked up, Bob!"
    • "Why would I pull out my teeth, Bob? They don't like that. That's a no-no."
    • "You have to be smart to get what you want... to be topside, breathe the air... to be with her... Isn't that what you want?"
  3. third audio hallucination: when Cole is in the airport bathroom

    • "You're thinking I don't exist except in your head. I can see that point of view. But you could still talk to me, couldn't you? Carry on a decent conversation?"
    • "Point of fact -- you don't belong here. It's not permitted to let you stay."

This leaves the scene where the voice appears to come from the homeless man Louie:

  • Louie: "They got that tracking device on you... In the tooth, Bob! Right? But I fooled 'em, old buddy!" (reveals he has no teeth)

I believe Louie is telling the truth: he is a time traveller who has avoided returning to the future by removing his teeth. At the same time, Louie's use of "Bob" and the way he seems to sound like the raspy voice is explained earlier by Railly when Cole tells her she is in his dream:

  • James Cole: "I never knew it was you before."
  • Kathryn Railly: It wasn't me before, James. It's become me now because of...what's happening."

Railly was wrong then -- it was her in Cole's dream. But the phenomenon she describes does occur when after meeting Louie, Cole -- in a state of extreme mental fatigue -- retroactively associates the raspy voice with Louie.

share|improve this answer

Louie is Cole. Cole is Louie. From the future, and they meet as they go back and forward in time don't you see. Cole is stuck in an infinite loop, replaying his life over and over, as he dies he lives, he lives just to die again, infront of his younger self. Louie is Cole.

share|improve this answer
but if Cole dies in the end, when was he Louie? As seen in the movie, Cole can't be Louie. He was never older and toothless. – Luciano Mar 25 at 15:59

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.