Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I saw Star Wars the weekend it was released in L.A. I distinctly remember Luke trying to rope the scaffolding and missing when crossing the chasm with Leia. Leia gives him a kiss and says, "For Luck" while he reels in the rope and then he makes the second attempt and succeeds.

My confusion on this topic concerns the "Original Theatrical Release" DVDs which do not show this scene. Was this scene then edited out before the widescreen release or was it edited out later and then omitted from the "theatrical release" DVD set?

share|improve this question
2  
No, I am old enough that I will not refuse to call it "A New Hope." – Andrei Freeman Jan 30 '12 at 2:12
    
By all indications, the missed throw was never filmed, and people are "remembering" something that they never actually saw. Luke may have missed the first throw in one of the radio plays, and perhaps one of the novelizations, but all the known footage shows him throwing the hook only once, and succeeding on that first try. All the script drafts in which the chasm scene occurs also describe a single, successful throw, with no misses. – Swan Dec 30 '15 at 19:15
    
Sadly, I beg to differ/ I can't give any support other than trusting my memory on this as I have been searching for quite some time. – Andrei Freeman Dec 30 '15 at 19:37
2  
I saw Staw Wars 7 times in the first week, and several times thereafter. I saw Luke throw and miss. Don't tell me I dreamed it, or got it from another source -- I didn't read the novelization. My college friends and I discussed it after one of those 7 viewings and we all wondered why, while Luke was messing with the rope, that the stormtroopers didn't just shoot under the door. – user29615 Jan 7 at 8:53
    
I don't know whether to put this up as an answer, I'm just trying to look at it logically. Fisher describes the scene here and mentions no failed attempt (nor giving Luke a 'dirty look', which some people also seem to remember), just that Lucas told her to shoot the gun, say 'For luck' and swing. She then says they shot it in one take. And I'm guessing that this is that take. So it appears that this 'miss' was never even shot. – Walt May 14 at 14:27
up vote 16 down vote accepted

I just re-watched the scene on the "Widescreen Limited Edition" version of A New Hope. This is the one that contained not only the re-mastered and Lucas-ized update done in 2006, but also a copy of the earlier print that was not restored. (And you can see a lot of clarity and picture stability issues in it.)

In that print, Luke throws the line and hook, it hooks, and he pulls on it, and Leia kisses him before they swing across. That's how I remember it from 1977 onwards, at least the kiss. (That she gives him a kiss before they swing across.)

However, this is the version that had the echo added to the dialogue between Luke and Leia, so it had already been altered from the original 1977 version of Star Wars. I know this echo was added for an early re-release that was before 1981. (I won't go into the landmarks of my life, but let's just say I know it was out before 1981, and likely before 1980, when The Empire Strikes Back came out.) That means, with this print, which is the earliest available (remastering was done later, after the echo was added), we can only go back to around 1980 at the earliest.

For what it's worth, I have always been puzzled by that, as well. I thought I remembered Luke throwing the line once, it not catching, and having to throw it again, but it's not in this print. (I am positive, though, that the kiss was always just before they swung across the line -- trust me, you see a movie like this as a teen on a date with a girl you've been drooling over for a few months, you remember every kissing scene in the movie!)

So if it did exist, it was cut before 1980 or 1981 and it's going to be almost impossible to find any version of the film to back up that it was once there.

share|improve this answer
    
Is there a pre-1980 laser disc publication? – Dronz Dec 30 '15 at 6:58
    
According to this the earliest Laserdisc release of A New Hope was in the 1980s. While a few movies were out, in the US, before 1980 (notably Jaws), this is before VHS or Beta was at a price where any but the wealthy could afford one. – Tango Dec 30 '15 at 17:36

The missed grappling hook throw (in the film version) seems to be a myth. Google "Luke misses grappling hook" and peruse the results.

For instance, here, and here, and here, and here, and here.

It seems that people remember this sequence from non-movie materials - novelizations, radio plays, story books, etc., but attribute it to the movie itself. Despite the "memories" of many people like yourself, there is no evidence whatsoever that the missed throw was ever filmed. The best answer is that your mind is playing tricks on you. This kind of thing happens - it is why eyewitness testimony is unreliable.

share|improve this answer
    
I still don't buy that. I've seen movies that have had bits cut out from soon after the initial release (for instance, in the 1980s Batman, the Joker's "Where does he get those wonderful toys?" was soon cut to "Get those wonderful toys.") It was a long time from when I saw the movie until I could read the book, if I ever read it. – Tango Dec 30 '15 at 17:39
    
@Tango - I saw the Michael Keaton Batman movie in the theater 8 or 9 times over about a month or so after it came out, and that line was always in it. It is so iconic that it is one of the most frequently quoted lines from the film. It even got an homage several years later in Mallrats. I recently saw the movie again on tv, and it is still there. Probably a bad example for you to use, because I have never heard of it being edited out. I could be wrong, but I don't think it was ever altered. – Swan Dec 30 '15 at 17:55
    
It was removed. Yes, I saw a later version with it in, but I remember being there with a friend, waiting for the line, and it being cut - and both my friend and I looked at each other in shock that it was changed. – Tango Dec 30 '15 at 18:05
    
@Tango - I still have trouble believing that, but in any case, Star Wars is far more popular and obsessed-over than that version of Batman. If that footage existed, we would have seen it by now. Or someone at the studio, or George Lucas, Mark Hamill, or Carrie Fisher, would have mentioned it. There is a wealth of evidence that people are conflating different media in their memories. – Swan Dec 30 '15 at 18:10
1  
These comments show us why eyewitness testimony is worthless. – Swan Jan 7 at 21:10

It's certainly possible that you're remembering the events of the Star Wars Storybook

enter image description here

or the film's official novelisation

Luke didn’t reply. Instead, he removed a small but heavy power unit from the utility belt of his armor and tied one end of the cable around it. Making sure the wrapping was secure, he stepped as close to the edge of their uncertain perch as he dared.

Whirling the weighted end of the cord in increasing circles, he let it arc across the gorge. It struck an outcropping of cylindrical conduits on the other side and fell downward. With forced patience he pulled the loose line back in, then recoiled it for another try.

Once again the weighted end orbited in ever greater circles, and again he flung it across the gap. He could feel the rising heat behind him as he let it go, heat from the melting metal doorway.

This time the heavy end looped around an outcropping of pipes above, wrapped itself several times around, and slipped, battery end down, into a crack between them.

share|improve this answer
    
This actually corroborates the investigation because these books are usually written in conjunction with the final edits before the film sees first release. – Andrei Freeman Jun 13 at 13:39

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.