Take the 2-minute tour ×
Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and tv enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Internet says "Black comedy is a form of comedy in which serious issues such as cannibalism, rape, genocide, terminal illnesses, etc. are treated humorously". But I don't see any comedy scenes in American psycho and all. Can someone explain me what is black comedy please?

share|improve this question
1  
I guess the boundary between black comedy and satire (which the first two certainly are, haven't seen the third, though I remember reviews calling it a black comedy) is rather soft. Of course comedy doesn't always lie in somebody slipping on a banana peel (exaggeration intended). –  Napoleon Wilson Apr 17 '13 at 7:59
2  
Who says American Psycho and Fight Club are 'black comedies'? –  Oliver_C Apr 17 '13 at 10:49
4  
Its not an answer to your question - but some scenes in American Psycho are definitely meant to be comedic - the business card comparison scene, the monolog about Huey Louis and the News - his entire persona is the epitome of a shallow rich guy - his inner monolog is hilarious. The whole movie is meant to be a satire about 80's Yuppies. –  iandotkelly Apr 17 '13 at 13:17
    
I would also echo @ChristianRau - AP and Fight Club are more satirical than comedy - but certainly contain humor. In Bruges is more of a black comedy - almost a situation comedy - two hitmen on a vacation in a picturesque town. –  iandotkelly Apr 17 '13 at 13:37
    
I'd say the guy flipping out over the egg shell color of a business card is...pretty damn comical. –  DustinDavis Apr 17 '13 at 19:41
show 1 more comment

2 Answers 2

Black Comedy and Satire are not quite two forms of the same thing. Satire is not always funny and is used to convey a message on a topic, while Black Comedy can be a part of a Satirical message. If you are familiar at all with the movie M*A*S*H, it is a black comedy about the Korean War. The Television series of the same name that spawned from that movie was a Satire that contained many of the same elements of Black Comedy, while in the later years took on and presented messages on more modern issues.

That said, as was pointed out in the comments, you need to examine the individual scenes and elements of each movie to understand why they are Black Comedies. The overall message of Life and Times of a Serial Killer may not be a funny one when you watch American Psycho, but as pointed out the business card scene, monologues, chainsaw dropped down the center of the staircase scene, and others are all Black Comedic scenes; humorous views on darker subjects. In Bruges had multiple darkly funny scenes... remember the hitman who chances his mind when his target is about to commit suicide, and the interaction immediately following it? The local girl's boyfriend who gets shot with the blank? The dwarf shot with the dum-dum bullet so the fact that his head is completely gone leads to the incorrect assumption that he is a child? All black comedic moments in a movie that itself is about death and tragedy. Fight Club... too many funny scenes to list, and all of them black. Learning later that the whole idea of the fight club was started by one guy beating the crap out of himself in a parking lot. Being beaten bloody itself isn't necessarily funny, but in this context you can laugh.

Black Comedy.

Is getting shot funny? No. in Pineapple Express, Danny McBride's character being shot multiple times, as well as the way he is shot, and still surviving? Funny. Black Comedy.

share|improve this answer
    
wow.. thanks Bon.. –  bumblebee87 Apr 18 '13 at 4:20
add comment

It might help to not think of black comedy as being defined as being humor about "cannibalism, rape, genocide, terminal illnesses," but rather to think of it as gallows humor.

Gallows humor is, loosely, defined as humor in the face of impossible situations. The most famous historical example is probably Oscar Wilde, on his death bed, saying "either that wallpaper goes, or I do." In other words, it's not so much jokes ABOUT eating people or cancer or anything likewise unpleasant, but about finding some humor within those situations.

Before we get too uplifting here, remember that the humor can be seen from either side in an "impossible situation" with an agressor/victim.

American Psycho has a number of scenes like this. Remember when Bateman is about to kill his buddy and yet instead of threatening him, all he can think to do is wax poetic about Huey Lewis and the News. It's hip to be square, isn't it? Even with an axe in your hand? Another famous movie example is the bit about chianti and fava beans from Silence of the Lambs. Joking around in a very, very dangerous situation.

The flip, and actually perhaps the more classic side, is one in which humor is found in the the face of the seemingly endless or impossible to escape misfortune of the protaganist. The best (well, I say best, but usually when I say that I just mean my favorite so... :) ) example in film might be After Hours, a movie in which our increasingly desperate hero consistently finds himself in what are (fairly, if lightly) terrifying situations that are also increasingly funny. There's not too much to do but laugh as he tries, and keeps on failing, to escape SoHo.

And Bon makes the other point I would have liked to, but probably more eloquently than I could have, which is, of course, always, always context!

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.